Blake Holly Hollis is following her dream to open an ice-creamery near her upstate town of Christmas Cove when she meets fellow chef, Theodore Black. They find themselves on opposite sides of Main Street and opposite sides of a coveted small business grant for one lucky shop owner. It's a race to Independence Day when the winner will be announced.

As the summer sun heats up, so does their rivalry. When the mischief and pranks go too far, will they find themselves fooled or falling in love instead?