Four and Twenty Blackbirds: The Trial of Paul Petry: The Beginning

Mars Hill Church was one of the fastest-growing churches in America. Led by the gifted and controversial Mark Driscoll, it attracted thousands of young Christians seeking biblical conviction, authentic community, and a faith worth living for. To many, it appeared to be a remarkable success story.

But beneath the growth, a leadership crisis was quietly unfolding.

When two elders raised concerns about proposed bylaw changes that concentrated authority within the church, few could have imagined the consequences. A simple challenge soon escalated into one of the defining moments in Mars Hill's history. Elders Paul Petry and Bent Meyer were removed from leadership and placed on trial. Friendships fractured. Families suffered. Trust was broken. And a shadow was cast over the church that would eventually lead to its eventual collapse in 2014.

Written by an insider who lived through these events, Four and Twenty Blackbirds is a firsthand account of a controversy that continues to raise difficult questions nearly two decades later.

At the heart of the story lies one troubling question:

How could twenty-four seasoned, qualified, and respected elders fail to lead when their leadership was most needed?

The title comes from the old English nursery rhyme Sing a Song of Sixpence and its famous line about "four and twenty blackbirds baked in a pie." For the author, the image became a metaphor for the twenty-four elders who sat at the center of this story. These were not foolish men. They were not inexperienced men. They had been carefully examined, trained, and entrusted with spiritual authority. Many were gifted leaders, devoted husbands, and sincere Christians.

Yet when a fellow elder stood before them in need of fairness, courage, and accountability, something went terribly wrong.

This book does not present a simple story of heroes and villains. Nor does it attempt to explain away failure by pointing to a single individual. Instead, it explores the uncomfortable reality that good people are capable of remaining silent when courage is required, and that organizations can drift from their stated values while believing they remain faithful to them.

More than a story about church politics, Four and Twenty Blackbirds is a reflection on leadership, loyalty, fear, repentance, forgiveness, and the immense cost of silence.

It is also deeply personal.

The author writes not as an outside observer, but as someone who experienced the events firsthand. He supported Paul Petry during the trial and faced consequences of his own for speaking out. Yet he is equally clear that he does not stand above those whose actions he critiques. Throughout the book he acknowledges his own failures, weaknesses, and sins, recognizing that all people ultimately stand in need of grace.

Readers familiar with The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill podcast will recognize many of the people and events described in these pages. Yet this book offers something different: the perspective of someone who lived through the controversy and spent years reflecting on what happened, why it happened, and what lessons can be learned from it.

Ultimately, Four and Twenty Blackbirds is not simply a story about Mars Hill Church. It is a story about human nature. It is a story about what happens when truth becomes costly, when loyalty conflicts with conviction, and when good people fail to use the voice they never truly lost.

Most of all, it is a story about grace, repentance, and the possibility of healing even after profound failure.

Binding Type: Paperback
Publisher: Robthainsmith.com
Published: 06/03/2026
ISBN: 9798240902529
Pages: 268
Weight: 0.80lbs
Size: 9.00h x 6.00w x 0.56d