It's been a year since Andy Stevens attended leadership camp and changed her whole perspective. Now, she's back at camp Follow the Leader as a counselor with the optimistic goal of helping campers just like she was: timid, withdrawn, and in need of a confidence injection. She's even brought along her new boyfriend Eric.

But when she arrives to find Lucas from last summer waiting for her, her plans are thrown into a tailspin. Lucas helps her to lead a wild pack of extroverted campers, but he has an ulterior motive: to win Andy back. Now she's torn between the boy who stole her heart and the boy who is trying to fix it.