This is the question seventeen-year-old Alli Mancini keeps asking herself.

At every turn, she's mocked for her Christian faith and harassed by two popular girls who have it out for her. And whenever she sees Chad Barton, she remembers how he humiliated her and shattered her heart.

With graduation coming soon, moving to California for a fresh start feels like the right idea.

But which will be harder-leaving or staying?

Alli's best friend, Tessa, is hurting and Alli feels responsible. She'd been at the party the night Tessa was kidnapped by traffickers, and Alli wonders if she could've done more to protect her friend that night. It's been months since her escape, but Tessa continues to wrestle with the darkness that threatens to overcome her. Alli fears that leaving Tessa in her fragile state would only cause her more pain.

Then there's Anthony. Good-looking and an all-around amazing guy. Anthony's feelings for her are obvious and Alli can't ignore the awakening in her own heart. Would she miss out on what could have been between them if she left?

No matter what she decides, there are challenges ahead for her.

In desperation, Alli turns to the one source she should've started with, knowing that trusting God will lead her to make the right choice.

But does she remember how to trust God?